Arizona governor signs toughest immigration law

By David Schwartz

PHOENIX (BestGrowthStock) – Arizona Governor Jan Brewer on Friday signed into effect the toughest immigration law in the United States, which President Barack Obama singled out as a “misguided” effort that showed the need for national reform.

Police in the border state with Mexico will now be required to determine if people are in the country illegally if there is “reasonable suspicion” that is the case — which critics charge will open the door to racial profiling.

Immigration is a bitterly contested issue in the United States, where some 10.8 million illegal immigrants live and work in the shadows. But until recently it has been eclipsed at the national level by other issues such as healthcare and financial reform, angering many Latino supporters of Obama.

Several thousand people gathered outside the state capitol in Phoenix ahead of the governor’s announcement, mostly opponents carrying signs saying “We Are Human” and “Enough is Enough.”

Mexico’s foreign minister, Patricia Espinosa, said the bill could damage the relationship between Mexico and Arizona, which have strong commercial ties.

An estimated 460,000 illegal immigrants live in the desert state, which also straddles the main point of entry for illegal immigrants crossing into the United States from Mexico.

The bill — passed by the Republican-controlled state Senate this week and signed by Brewer, a Republican — is expected to spark a legal challenge and is already a hot issue in the run-up to U.S. congressional elections in November.

“If we continue to fail to act at a federal level, we will continue to see misguided efforts opening up around the country,” Obama said earlier on Friday at a ceremony swearing in new U.S. citizens.

Concern over border-related crime spiked late last month in Arizona — where Senator John McCain faces a tough challenge in the Republican primary race from fiery conservative J.D. Hayworth — after a prominent rancher was shot dead by a suspected smuggler close to the Mexican border.

Brewer said the new law strengthened Arizona and would help keep it safe from drug cartels and other threats. “It protects all of us, every Arizona citizen and everyone here in our state lawfully and it does so while ensuring that the constitutional rights of all in Arizona remain solid,” she said.

Sher said Arizona had acted because Washington had not, and she said police would be trained on the concept of what constitutes “reasonable suspicion” that someone is an illegal immigrant. “I do not know what an illegal immigrant looks like,” she said in response to a question.


While Republican-backed measures like this anger reform supporters, the Democratic Party fears a backlash from Latinos in the November congressional elections because of a lack of movement on the issue since Obama took office.

Passage of the law re-energized calls from leading Congressional Democrats late on Friday to push for a comprehensive federal overhaul.

“Today’s signing of new immigration laws by Arizona’s governor provides another important example of why we need to fix our broken system,” said Senate Majority leader Harry Reid, who faces a tough reelection fight in Nevada, which Hispanics helped swing for Obama in 2008.

“Republicans and Democrats need to work together to pass comprehensive reform that is tough on people who break the law, fair to taxpayers, respectful of civil liberties and practical to implement,” he added.

The Arizona law is the harshest of a growing number of immigration measures passed by U.S. states.

It requires state and local police officers to arrest those unable to provide documentation proving they are in the country legally. It also makes it a crime to transport someone who is an illegal immigrant, and to hire day laborers off the street.

Passage of the law, slated to take effect 90 days after the current legislative session adjourns, prompted immediate and strong reactions. In Mexico, the foreign minister said criminalizing illegal immigrants was the wrong approach.

“This law … affects the relationship between Arizona and Mexico and obligates the Mexican government to reevaluate the viability and usefulness of our cooperation,” Foreign Minister Espinosa said in a prepared statement.

“The Mexican government will use all its available resources to defend the rights and dignity of Mexicans in Arizona,” Espinosa said.

But local Republicans were upbeat on the measure.

“It’s a great day for the people of Arizona because once implemented we will all be safer,” state Representative John Kavanagh, a Republican who backed the measure, told Reuters.

“The message this sends to the country is that when the federal government lets us down we know what to do and the message it sends to illegal aliens is don’t come to Arizona.”

Janet Murguia, president of civil rights group the National Council of La Raza and an opponent of the measure, expressed deep disappointment “that Governor Brewer chose politics over sound policy,” in signing the bill into law.

“The passage of (the bill) will legitimize racial profiling in Arizona and it goes against our laws and our values as a country,” she added.

Stock Market Research Tools

(Additional reporting by Tabassum Zakaria in Washington, Mica Rosenberg and Armando Tovar in Mexico City; Writing by Tim Gaynor and Peter Henderson)

Arizona governor signs toughest immigration law